August 2026:

Published in 2016, this novel is based upon the vicissitudes faced by Shostakovich, the Russian composer who faced severe criticism and constraint by the Communist Party, particularly during Stalin’s rule. His works, though appreciated by music lovers, were publicly attacked by those in power, as they were said to flout the values and tastes of the Party.

Barnes presents a detailed picture of Shostakovich’s dread of punishment and the tactics he used to survive and protect his family, whilst continuing to practise his art and follow his inspiration. He was forced to deliver prepared speeches at home and abroad and articles were written and published by the Communists in his name. In a final betrayal of his conscience, he was forced to join the Party after much resistance.

The group felt that Barnes’ presentation of Art versus political power, the permanence of Art and the self-loathing of the embattled, compromised composer were portrayed sensitively and intelligently. Some felt the narrator’s style to be rather distant and analytical. One opinion was that a greater exploration of Shostakovich’s music would have enriched the novel and our understanding of the composer’s resistance, why he was such a master of classical music and so popular with the people.

On balance we found it a good book.

Maggie Doherty

---